Working to make government more effective

Comment

Modernising post-government employment rules is long overdue

Reform of the business appointment rules is an important part of the bigger picture on opening up the civil service

Civil servants in Whitehall

The government should adopt recommendations set out in the civil service commission’s review into the rules, and the practices, regulating post-government jobs – but this is one part of the puzzle of breaking open the service, writes Hannah Keenan

Restrictions on the type of work an official can do after leaving the civil service are governed by BARs – the business appointment rules. Once administered by the advisory committee on business appointments (ACOBA), the BARs for senior (directors general and permanent secretaries) civil servants and special advisers is, as of 2025, overseen by the civil service commission, the arms-length body that regulates recruitment into the civil service.  

It is a system which, the institute has long argued, is in need of overhauling – and so a new report by the civil service commission is welcome. It sets out recommendations which will, if accepted, contribute to a more porous and expert civil service, and government should reform the BARs in line with the review recommendations. It will then need to go much further to open up the civil service. 

Business appointment rules have been harming the civil service 

While developing people and skills is crucial, part of creating an effective workforce will always mean being able to access experience and expertise from outside when it is required. Something with which the civil service has long struggled.  

There are a whole host of reasons, cultural and structural, behind that. But BARs are one part of the picture. As the Institute’s research from 2022 set out, the BARs have been acting as a disincentive for external applicants, in particular senior ones to technical roles. The rules could, in theory, restrict you from taking up work in your field of expertise for up to two years after leaving the civil service. And in process terms, even if there are ultimately no restrictions on your future employment, it might take you months to get clearance to take up that role – by which time the window may well have closed. That is very real uncertainty, and a very real disincentive for outsiders to take up a role in the civil service. It is not the only reason external experts don’t come in, but it is a factor. 

Government should act on the commission's review 

That the civil service commission, which already regulates entry, is leading this work on exits for senior officials is a good start; career shapes are shifting and the service should be encouraging – with appropriate ethical safeguards – careers that move in and out of government. The rules have not been meaningfully updated since the 1970s, and no longer reflect the reality of modern work or the skills the service needs. This review should result in a much-needed update.  

Two things are particularly welcome. First, a recognition that the current rules conflate sector expertise with improper advantage, and that this must change. The civil service needs experts, and there should be a sizeable chunk of them who are able to come into government and return to their field of expertise without being unduly punished for doing so. Second, the recognition that much of this is about culture and process efficiency, rather than only about the rules themselves. There is no point updating the rules if the myths around them still hold, or if it will still take months for officials to receive the all-clear on low-risk roles.

The government should act on the commission’s review, reforming the system so that it provides greater clarity for officials, and more proportionality. The review recommends, for example, that for fixed-term appointments of a year or less, conditions should be agreed upon before employment is taken up. As the Institute has previously argued, it should be possible, before joining a role, to see very clearly what restrictions on your activity will look like after you leave. 

Opening up the civil service will need far more than BARs reform 

These recommendations are still only one small piece of the civil service’s ongoing struggle with porosity. As the cabinet secretary said in her recent lecture, “we disincentivise our brightest talent from stepping outside the Civil Service to gain vital experience, and bringing that critical knowledge back”.  

Unblocking this problem requires a series of inter-linked initiatives. More recruitment, especially in central government departments, needs to be done externally. New talent can’t find its way in if many job adverts are still only visible to civil servants. That in turn means addressing the underlying reasons, or perceptions, that drive recruitment from the existing pool of civil servants: security vetting takes too long; onboarding is patchy; there’s no consistent training offer so new team members need to already ‘get’ government; the recruitment process favours internal candidates anyway.

The government is making good steps on some of this, including the new national school of government and public service, and the decision to scrap the ‘success profiles’ currently used to recruit. There are pockets of excellence that show it can be done differently without the system falling over, such as the recruitment exemptions in place for the AI Security Institute.  

Being able to bring in more external people while controlling the size of the civil service also requires better tools to increase the number of leavers from the civil service. A sharper practice and culture around poor performance management, and tighter workforce planning are all part of the same picture.

BARs reform is a helpful piece of the puzzle of breaking open the civil service. But it is only one part of a much bigger ambition on porosity and reform.

Administration
Burnham government
Publisher
Institute for Government

Related content

13 NOV 2026 Podcast

Wherefore start thou, Romeo?

The Guardian’s Rowena Mason joins the podcast team for expert analysis of cabinet secretary Antonia Romeo's agenda for changing the civil service.