Working to make government more effective

Comment

Milburn’s ambitious NEETs reform vision leaves difficult questions unanswered

The conclusion of Alan Milburn’s review of young people Not in Education, Employment or Training (NEETs) is wide ranging and ambitious.

Former health secretary Alan Milburn speaks to the media on the publication of the interim Milburn Report into Young People and Work
Alan Milburn has provided both a clear diagnosis and a clear political vision.

Ben Paxton welcomes the attention that Alan Milburn has brought to problems with the social security system – but says his ambitious reforms leave government facing a series of difficult decisions

Alan Milburn’s highly ambitious NEETs review sets out a diagnosis of “whole system failure” and calls for a “whole system reset” solution. The recommendations run well into triple figures, and span several departments and all tiers of government. He wants an expanded, personalised and prevention-focused system of support to help young people into earning or learning, which is absolutely the right direction of travel for this broken system. 

Milburn’s review sets out important steps towards this goal, but by leaning heavily on legal guarantees of support without specifying funding for them, and not answering big questions on the shape of a new youth benefits system, difficult decisions remain on how to put this review into practice. 

A strong system of local employment support will better support young people

Milburn is right to put a new local system of support for NEETs at the heart of his proposals. Young people face multiple barriers to employment, which no single department can address. Strategic authorities are the right level for setting up a coherent, integrated system of support since they aim to reflect labour market geographies and have responsibilities for relevant policy areas, including skills and local growth (and are due to be aligned with boundaries for other relevant services in the future). 

The review proposes a ‘Youth Opportunity Service’ in every area of England by 2029. This would engage people early, and create a personalised ‘Participation Plan’ for each young person who is NEET (similar to the ‘Personalised Support Plan’ the IfG recently recommended). It would bring together services – including health, skills and employment support – and act as a single front door for both young people and employers. The review also recommends significant expansion of apprenticeships and further education provision and £1.1bn of subsidies to encourage employers to hire young people – with the Youth Opportunity Service connecting people to job opportunities and this support.

Milburn’s Youth Opportunity Service is a national model but would, crucially, be designed and delivered by strategic authorities. A ‘Participation Agreement’ would set out multi-year funding for strategic authorities, and the outcomes against which they would be held accountable. The focus on outcomes is right, but this system should work alongside the wider accountability and devolved funding model outlined in the upcoming devolution white paper – rather than try to work outside these structures.

New targets and legal guarantees will not automatically lead to better support

The review proposes several new laws and statutory guarantees. The most significant of these are an ‘Opportunity Guarantee’ for every young person of a route into education, employment or training, and a ‘Support Guarantee’ of access to relevant health and employment support. Strategic authorities would be responsible for delivering these through the Youth Opportunity Service, with details of the guarantees specified in future legislation and funding as part of the ‘Participation Agreement’.  

Milburn also proposes new targets and statutory responsibilities for the health and education systems. For schools, these include more ambitious targets for school readiness at age five and work experience becoming a statutory duty. The NHS would be required to fast track access to mental health support for NEETs, alongside enforcing new maximum waiting time standards for youth mental health services. Integrated Care Boards (ICBs) would also be legally required to “work with MSAs and other local agencies to increase youth participation”, and ensure services are integrated.

Targets can help improve performance, and legal entitlements can help individuals access services and enforce minimum standards. But it matters how legal entitlements are defined, enforced and funded. Ultimately, an entitlement is only as good as the support that is actually available.

There is a risk that already stretched services are being asked to do more, without them getting the funding needed to do so. Layering responsibilities in this way can be counterproductive. It can distort wider service provision, including squeezing spend on more preventative activity to fund statutory requirements, and restrict local services rather than supporting flexible and collaborative outcomes-based working. For example, requirements already in place for ICBs and local authorities to work together on children’s social care and SEND have not successfully aligned incentives or led to better outcomes. Strong cross-agency working is more often enabled by clear outcomes and accountability, flexibility to share budgets and sustainable multi-year funding – which the Milburn review proposes elsewhere.

Milburn’s benefits plan doesn’t address contentious eligibility questions    

Milburn’s review provides both a clear diagnosis of the social security system’s many problems and a clear political vision of what reform should achieve. He proposes a new separate benefits system for young people, with a new ‘Youth Allowance’ to replace Universal Credit standard and health elements, alongside a new youth disability benefits system. 

The high-level principles of Milburn’s vision are correct: a new system should better connect people to the wider range of support they need, rather than narrowly pigeon-holing them into oversimplified benefit categories. But the details of what this would mean in practice – and the fundamental but difficult questions about eligibility – remain unanswered. 

The review does not address the important and highly contentious issues of defining who should be eligible for support with ‘demonstrable extra costs’ from their disability, or who counts as ‘profoundly disabled’. Given the breadth of this review, not addressing these questions here may be reasonable. But these choices on eligibility will determine what savings these reforms are expected to deliver, which will be important for working out how the new system is funded at next year’s spending review. Proposing a new system, but leaving these questions unanswered, means the coming months will feature significant public and parliamentary debate on eligibility.  

Strong political leadership and sustained government focus are vital for success

Adults over 25 are outside the scope of this review, and the Timms review will make recommendations on disability benefits shortly. But Milburn rightly points out that the government should reform social security for all adults – a challenge which will, along with navigating the debates over the youth benefits system and then its delivery, require strong political leadership.

The attention Milburn has brought to the problems in the social security system is welcome – and he is right that this is a unique opportunity for change. 

But the ability of this impressive review to drive forward meaningful improvements will depend on government sustaining focus on improving the system, even when the difficult decisions in 2027 arrive. Having Milburn at the helm of a new Youth Opportunities Unit at the centre of government to shape and deliver the government’s response, and reporting directly to the prime minister, should give it a strong chance of success. 
 

Political party
Labour
Administration
Burnham government
Publisher
Institute for Government

Related content

13 NOV 2026 Podcast

Wherefore start thou, Romeo?

The Guardian’s Rowena Mason joins the podcast team for expert analysis of cabinet secretary Antonia Romeo's agenda for changing the civil service.