Parliament returns: Will the government take scrutiny seriously?
Labour's promise of a new approach to parliamentary scrutiny is about to be tested.
As Keir Starmer’s cabinet and reshuffled official team return to Westminster with a challenging autumn ahead, Hannah White identifies some of the signals which will indicate whether the new government is fulfilling its commitment to treat parliament more seriously
As the Labour government approaches 100 days in power, Keir Starmer and his ministers are only now having to engage with parliament – and parliamentary scrutiny. The summer recess, followed by the party conference season, have seen the Palace of Westminster play a bit-part role since the general election, but that is set to change.
Parliament’s committees will soon be up and running
Select committees are expected to be up and running next month, bringing scrutiny to bear on the actions of the new government. With chairs elected in September, political parties at Westminster will now choose their committee members – though there may be some disruption to membership caused by a Conservative reshuffle following the conclusion of the party’s leadership election. The whips will also be choosing the chairs of unelected committees, and putting those names to the House.
The Liaison Committee – the committee responsible for taking oral evidence from the PM – can meet once chairs are all in place. Because Labour’s large majority has given them the vast majority of chairs, it is to be hoped that the government will return to the former practice of allowing the chairs to select the Liaison Committee chair from amongst their number, rather than replicating the last government’s controversial decision to parachute in a government-selected chair – Sir Bernard Jenkin.
There is also a welcome new addition to the select committee landscape – the Modernisation Committee chaired by the Leader of the House Lucy Powell. This is expected to begin its work with further reflection on MPs’ outside earnings. An early test will be how it handles the results of an open call for ideas about other questions it should consider, with the large influx of new MPs having many questions about the practices and procedures of the House they would like to see considered –from use of time in the chamber, to childcare, to participation in debates. How Mod Com chooses to use its time – and how it works with other domestic committees such as Procedure and Administration – will be important tests of whether this new committee is genuinely a mechanism for parliamentary reform or simply a tool for the government to introduce changes it wants to see.
Will the government deliver its promise to improve legislative scrutiny?
Whether the government fulfils its promises to improve standards of legislative scrutiny will be illustrated by the choices it makes about the introduction and timetabling of bills. The key issue will be the balance it strikes between being seen to legislate rapidly (meeting commitments to introduce bills in the first 100 days – an unfortunate concept beloved of manifesto writers with decidedly negative consequences for the quality of such legislation) and being able to prepare detailed and robust legislation.
Drafting legislation at speed inevitably means unforeseen consequences are more likely, and parliament is more likely to be asked to gift excessive regulation-making powers to ministers in lieu of being able to scrutinise detail on the face of the bill. This is a risk – for example – with the promised Employment Rights Bill, which is intended to provide new rights to workers.
Another issue will be the time the government allows for scrutiny of bills in public bill committee and how it chooses to constrain its own use of the less effective scrutiny provided by Committee of the Whole House. The King’s Speech also identified four potential draft bills as candidates for pre-legislative scrutiny. The establishment of joint committees to consider these bills would constitute a welcome up-tick in the use of this important scrutiny procedure.
The Private Members’ Bill procedure needs reform
The success of Kim Leadbeater in the Private Members’ Bill ballot and her decision to introduce a bill on Assisted Dying have already ensured that the Commons’ procedures by which backbenchers can legislate will assume a much higher profile than in recent years. Private Members’ Bills are a useful mechanism providing parliament with the opportunity to debate and decide on ethical issues which the government might not find time to discuss. But the idiosyncrasies of PMB procedure are difficult for the public (and MPs) to understand, and the government will need to take care that proceedings dealing with such an emotive subject do not appear to be arbitrarily curtailed nor that legislation is rushed through without sufficient scrutiny. Hopefully the process of considering the bill – including the impact it has on the bills brought forward by other backbenchers – will prompt MPs to engage in wider reflection about the inadequacies of PMB procedure – a subject that Mod Com might wish to consider.
There have been plenty of early tests for Keir Starmer and his government, but its experiences in parliament have, so far, been largely without incident. Previous administrations have often viewed Parliamentary scrutiny as a headache they could do without. Starmer would be wise to make a reality of his vaunted different approach. Taking scrutiny seriously will provide a different challenge for a prime minister and his team – but it is one that, ultimately, will help the government to deliver its priorities.
- Political party
- Labour
- Administration
- Starmer government
- Department
- Office of the Leader of the House of Commons
- Public figures
- Lucy Powell Keir Starmer
- Publisher
- Institute for Government