Working to make government more effective

Report

The Political Economy of Infrastructure in the UK

This paper reviews the accumulating evidence of problems in the way the UK makes strategic infrastructure decisions.

This paper reviews the accumulating evidence of problems in the way the UK makes strategic infrastructure decisions.

It identifies problems such as short-sightedness and lack of forward-looking strategy; failure to secure cross-party agreement, translated into high political risk; serious weaknesses in the evidence base, even in the cases where there is cross-party support; and failure to secure local community consent, which often leads to political procrastination.

The paper concludes that these problems stem from gaps in the institutional architecture for infrastructure investment decisions. It uses examples of individual policy areas and projects such as HS2 and the Thames Tideway to highlight the lack of adequate forums for structured, informed discussions about these policy decisions.

The paper argues that the political process must be improved to address this institutional gap, and it draws attention to several international examples that offer lessons for potential reform in the UK.

Publisher
Institute for Government

Related content

23 OCT 2014 Report

Housing That Works for All

This paper examines the housing affordability crisis, presenting evidence on the risk of distortions in favour of homeowners is economically striking.

02 APR 2024 Insight paper

Where next for levelling up?

This short paper highlights five key challenges that any government seeking to reduce regional inequalities will need to address.