Working to make government more effective

Comment

The Prime Minister cannot build a legacy after resigning

Theresa May is trying to secure a legacy beyond Brexit but she will only be remembered for what she did before announcing the date of her departure.

Theresa May is trying to secure a legacy beyond Brexit but – like all prime ministers – she will only be remembered for what she did before announcing the date of her departure, says Tim Durrant.

As Jeremy Hunt and Boris Johnson continue to vie for the votes of Conservative Party members, Theresa May will spend the weekend celebrating three years in Downing Street. While this is longer than many expected, with less than a fortnight left in office she is very much at the tail-end of her premiership. However, the Prime Minister is keeping busy as she continues to focus on the non-Brexit issues that she hoped to tackle months ago.

May’s attempts to build a non-Brexit legacy are proving expensive

The Prime Minister is travelling the country and making speeches on issues which she clearly feels strongly about: the importance of the Union; housebuilding; tackling challenges faced by disabled people; and the building of a monument to the Windrush generation. These announcements – including the creation of the Office for Tackling Injustices – hark back to her first speech as Prime Minister in July 2016.

But this flurry of announcements risks rushing through poorly-designed, expensive policies. We have already seen a commitment to net zero carbon emissions by 2050 approved by Parliament with no discussion of the challenges that such a target presents. And reports of a disagreement between Philip Hammond and the Prime Minister over how much money to make available for schools funding show that her ambitions are perhaps greater than her fiscally conservative Chancellor would like.

Previous prime ministers also spent their last days in office of in search of a legacy

David Cameron and Tony Blair were, like May, prime ministers who handed power to someone from their own party rather than losing it at a general election. And they also used their last few weeks in Downing Street trying to focus on issues other than the policies which ended up dominating their time in power.

Due to the curtailed Conservative leadership contest in 2016, Cameron only had around three weeks as a “caretaker” prime minister. He used that time to make speeches on British business successes, announced new schools and published plans for a monument (to British victims of overseas terrorism).

Tony Blair had over a month in 2007 between announcing his resignation and Gordon Brown taking over, though it was a long-expected handover. He also travelled the country and made speeches. These saw Blair make an announcement of extra support for young mothers, give a speech at a reception for charity leaders and setting out his views on the relationship between politicians and the media.

But the legacies of both prime ministers were established well before they embarked on their farewell tours. Whether your view of Cameron or Blair is positive or negative, it is likely to have been formed by the decisions they took at the height of their power, rather than in the dying days of their administrations.

Ultimately, the Prime Minister will be remembered for failing to see Brexit over the line

Theresa May will face the same issue. Her legacy will not be as someone who argued for more funding for schools against a recalcitrant Treasury, or as the creator of the Government Equalities Hub. Worthy as these decisions may be, Theresa May will, in the end, be remembered as the Prime Minister who was unable to get the UK out of the EU. That legacy was established months ago.

When accounts of Theresa May's time as Prime Minister are written in the years to come, political historians may yet reassess her tenure. Despite Theresa May's attempts to rewrite her legacy in a few short weeks before leaving office, their debates are unlikely to be informed by the hurried announcements that she made after handing in her notice.

Topic
Ministers
Position
Prime minister
Public figures
Theresa May
Publisher
Institute for Government

Related content

22 MAR 2024 Podcast

The prime minister's plot twists

The Spectator’s Isabel Hardman joins the IfG podcast team to discuss Conservative Party plots and Rachel Reeves' speech.